One of the major reasons why Kartik was worried about moving to India is the fact that I have zero adaptability. I have a well defined comfort zone and stepping out of my personal boundaries induces panic. Actually, even the thought of stepping out of my personal boundaries is enough to induce massive anxiety. Kartik is the opposite. He’s an adapter who can change his spots to suit his surroundings in a seemingly effortless manner. He knows what so say, when to say it, and how to say it. This is an advantage that most Indian people have against, well, anybody really—they’ve grown up in such cut throat competition that they can survive and adapt to anything. You can’t take time off for being sick, being depressed, recovering from an eating disorder…heck, you can’t even think of ever having an eating disorder in the first place. Kartik doesn’t really come into this group as he was born with a sizeable silver spoon in his mouth [as compared to members of what’s considered the middle class in India] but he definitely has the competitive Indian spirit that’s part hard-work, part aggression and part rigid practicality. From what I’ve seen, the most successful people here have been those who don’t get sick, multitask 24/7, simply do not give up under any circumstances, and those who have [what I’ve labelled] positive aggression.
![]() |
| Chaos on the Streets |
I am coming to terms with the fact that I am not remotely cut out to be that way. The grand epiphany puts me in a glitch as I wasn’t, how do I say this, born with a sizeable silver spoon in my mouth. Sure I was raised in relative comfort, but nothing that remotely resembled a silver spoon. Now in Canada, this wouldn’t have really mattered because most people can lead comfortable lives without having to be wealthy. You’ll get electricity, gas, central a/c and heating, proper insulation and decent plumbing for a much cheaper rate than you would in India. To put things into perspective having an a/c for each room, somewhat insulated windows, and half way decent plumbing is considered a luxury! Our summer electricity bills in Gurgaon come up to roughly two hundred Canadian dollars a month [in Toronto, it would be somewhere between $60 - $80 CAD]. As you can see <here> our apartment is a small two bedroom unit, so it’s not some massive place that requires the constant use of a/c. Gas prices are generally more expensive by 40 cents / litre. You have to pay for your kids schooling. Insurance companies are bigger shall we say sharks here than they are in the US. [Side Note: Ya know what India desperately needs? A Michael Moore! Imagine someone going to some Indian ministry with a camera and documentary crew.] Obviously, people here make a lot less money than they do in Canada so it’s mind boggling how they survive and still manage to save a lot more $ than your average Canadian.
![]() |
| Michael Moore |
I certainly miss Canadian life and values. There’s no pressure to throw yourself into your work to have a somewhat decent standard of living. You go to uni, get average grades, at the end of the day you’ll most likely get a starting salary of at least 30K a year. Healthcare is universal. Kids get an excellent tax payer funded education. Politicians actually work in public service [they may annoy you with their moustaches however…Jack Layton has a very annoying moustache]. And racism is um considered bad…VERY bad. [Side note: some people here complain that ‘white’ people are generally racist. I would highly disagree with this sentiment. From my experiences, I come to the conclusion that minorities are far more racist to each other than ‘white’ people are towards minorities. Ask a random Indian what he or she thinks of the appearance of a Chinese person (or vice versa). I can guarantee you that you will most likely get a response that a ‘white’ person would label as racist].
In India, there’s no license to feel bad about people stereotyping your behaviour based on your ethnic background. You have to take an aggressive step forward and say ‘well, eff you, your ethnic background is *insert a whole bunch of racist stereotypes here*.’
Speaking of ethnicity and culture, my maid, who hails from a Lama-Tamang background, has no clue about her heritage! She doesn’t speak Tamang, doesn’t know any significant Tamang festivals, and this bugs me in three ways. First, I feel like she should know at least something about her heritage! Second, I feel like I should know it too! Nepal is a culturally diverse country and if Mahendra-Mala can make a stupid chapter [on every book mind you] about the amiable qualities of cows, it can bloody well have chapters highlighting cultural diversity in Nepal. Third, I also feel that it’s none of my business to be telling my maid what she should know about her own culture. The last point particularly bugs me because I realize that my maid and I are alike. We’re classic textbook examples of human migration à loss of language / culture à assimilation à indifference to parent-culture.
Back to the topic—I can definitely understand why people get pissed when I complain about living in India. India has been nicer to me than it has to 97% of its own citizens. But I feel that life here is too chaotic [not necessarily a negative word] and I am not adapting to my surroundings fast enough. I’m okay with living in India for a few years but I’ve come to the resolute conclusion that I do not want to raise children here. Kartik turned out great! And he has his parents to thank for that. But I’ve seen rather numerous examples of people who I definitely do not want my children turning into.


You and I came here about the same time and I think we are at about the same place in our adjustment phase lol. I find India fascinating and torturous all at the same time. I too am fairly certain I won't be raising kids here either. I'm not sure I'll even bring them to visit until they are much older. I'm mortified at the thought of them playing in the street while traffic, cows and random ppl walk by which is common here. (Even for kids who can't be more than 2!) And the thoughts of all the steps and unsafe things around the house that we don't have to deal with in the west...it drives me crazy!
ReplyDeleteI think I've had about all I can stand of the chaos here. I'm just not into chaos and confusion and I can't find any organization here. My comfort zone is begging me to come home!
I live fairly well here, even though it is expensive. However, I'm really tired of it being so complicated to live this way. And you're right - there are a lot of things here that just aren't as comfy as the west.
If that pic you took of traffic is your neighborhood then be glad you don't live here. Traffic is much tighter here most of the day (I have vids on YouTube if you wanna see) and the streets are a lot worse off.
I love your straightforward writing style and your honesty! Don't feel bad about seeing the negative as well as the positive in India - we all need to vent once in a while, and you're clearly a long way off being one of those awful miserable expats who do nothing but moan!
ReplyDelete@White Bhabi--I'm terrified of them turning into jerks who drive drunk and bribe cops without a second thought. Hehe.
ReplyDeleteThe traffic jam wasn't from my neighborhood [it's a pic I found online], but I was stuck in a terrible jam on Monday. What bugged me the most was that people kept honking in spite of the fact that everyone was stuck. They were...not intelligent enough to realize that no one was moving and they didn't have the ...decency to make the wait comfortable for the rest of the people who were stuck.
@Chris: Hey there! Thanks for your comment. Feels like I've been seeing too much of the negative side of things lately...and being in Delhi doesn't help. I prefer Mumbai or Hyderabad hehe.
This article reminded me of your post: http://www.chillibreeze.com/articles/NRIlistssomeprosandconsoflivinginAmericaandIndia.asp
ReplyDeleteHey there! Thanks for the link. Interesting read. Lucky girl moved to Bangalore and Mumbai while we moved to Haryana.
ReplyDeleteI'm addicted to reading your blog because I've always wanted to find out what it's like for NRIs to return to India. Even though you're not one of them, your experiences come pretty close. I think many NRIs would react the same way that you have in certain situations.
ReplyDeleteAdditionally, I don't blame you for complaining about India. I have read about so many NRIs who had moved to India after retirement thinking life would be pleasant but came back due to the problems you mentioned above and many others.
ReplyDeleteYou might want to read this too: http://www.indiacurrents.com/articles/2011/04/19/domestic-divas.
ReplyDeleteAnother interesting article! See, the NRIs' with whom I grew up in the US (georgia) were raised in extremely traditional households. I would see them having a culture shock upon returning to India and realizing that the Indian upper-middle and upper classes have moved on into the 21st century.
ReplyDeleteYeah I definitely know of some people who have reacted the same way. I think that only people who are from the big cities (like Bombay, Delhi, Hyderabad or Bangalore or the surrounding areas) feel that way though.
ReplyDeleteGrass is always greener on the other side! I guess Canada is your comfort zone so you feel like returning back.
ReplyDeleteI know so many Indian people in the states who are well settled in their jobs but harbor similar feelings of not raising their kids in the states and raising them in India.
Both places have their positives and negatives but at the end of the day, the place that feels like home is the best.
I personally think American Born Indians turn out to be very confused and would hate to raise my kids in the states when the time comes.
- If Michael Moore comes to India , he would be beaten black and blue by the politician's bodyguards :), that is if he is lucky enough to not be killed by them.
p.s : love the traffic picture :)
@College Student--yup, I meant the urban crowd.
ReplyDelete@Fiesty Blogger--definitely agree that there are pros and cons to both places. My fiance agrues that if you raise children here then they'll turn out to be more adaptive and competitive.
About the American born Indians--hmm, my fiance's always said that he found the Indians raised abroad to be a hell of a lot more 'Indian' than the Indians he grew up with in India! And I'd agree with that sentiment.
hahaha, an Indian version of Michael Moore would probably be killed. That's what I love about the US/Canada--you can criticize politicians without having to fear torture and death.
Hi Kay sorry for suggesting in my last comment that you step outside your comfort zone...sounds like you're kind of already there!
ReplyDeleteI second Chris. You don't sound negative, you're just processing your experiences - and giving your readers a great read while at it :)
I agree. Indian kids are way more adaptive and competitive. And going by the way the economies of US and the other western countries are going right now, these two skills will be really needed by your kids when they grow up ,regardless of which country they are in.
ReplyDeleteyeah thats the sad part about India, there is a pseudo freedom of speech hence no michael moore's exist.I have a feeling this might change soon since people are so sick of corruption in India.
various people have commented that the reason behind absence of micheal moore is "lack of freedom of speech" in india . i certainly don't agree.
ReplyDeleteyes, there are not many good documentaries. the reason in my opinion is lack of "documentary making culture" and not a lack of freedom. also indian journalism in electronic media is yet to mature. so the thrust there is more on entertainment than information.
there are indeed some hard hitting documentaries. for example - "the final solution" by rakesh sharma. last i have heard he is very alive and in good health. no one as far as i know even try to torture or murder arundhuti roy either despite the fact very few people buy her arguments. there also doesn't seem to be any lack of articles criticising govt. or other organisations.
there certainly are various acts of intolerance. i may even agree that west has a better record but claiming that in india "a michael moore" will be tortured and murdered is not only grossly unfair but also very superficial.
@Kay and FiestyBlogger - I disagree. I think that over time Americans will become more adaptable than Indians. Here we're probably going to see an economic decline throughout our lives and that India will see a rise. This automatically means that our standards of living here will decrease but will increase over there. Usually only people with lower standards of living are easily adaptable.
ReplyDelete@Carvaka--I'm going to disagree with the superficial part. I'm not going to give a lengthy argument since I don't want to make this into a debate blog, but I'm going to give Binayak Sen's treatment as an example. Sure, things may be changing in India, but who you are and the kind of family you are born into also makes a huge difference. Michael Moore comes from a working class family from Flint Michigan.
ReplyDelete@College Student--I have a tough time buying that. Americans get super sensitive when you bring up topics about obesity and spending. I doubt they'll toughen up to real issues anytime soon.
@Taswin--Thanks for the comment! I'm definitely out of my comfort zone right now. It'll take me a bit to relax and get used to my surroundings.
ReplyDelete@kay,
ReplyDeleteexcellent example.
this year SC has rejected the sedition charge and granted him bail.
yes, he had spent around 2 years in an indian jail (not a thing to be taken lightly ) but it seems to me that those who wanted to silence him were not exactly successful.
sorry for "argumentative indian" bit i wlll try to keep myself shorter and sweeter next time. :)
Hey! No worries! I think you brought up some great points. I will definitely check out The Final Solution when I have the time. But I do wonder though, what if it had been a Mohammad Yousuf instead of a Rakesh Sharma, trying to make a doc on the Gujarat riots. How successful would Mohammad Yousuf had been?
ReplyDeleteIt took a lot of international pressure for the MP gov to lay off of Sen. I think India's changing for the better in terms of freedom of speech and right to criticize those in power. However, I believe that it's easier for certain pockets of society to be more 'vocal' than others. Namely, upper middle and upper class people of a Hindu background. Heck, I've written a critical post on Hindu mythology on this blog and people who are ticked off by the post seem to back off once they realize that I'm from a Hindu background myself.
mohammad yousuf? - hmmmm, that is a tricky question.
ReplyDeletewell, there is a hindu artist who got some minor thrashing from the VHP activists for depicting ganesha (?) in a controversial way . then there was deepa mehta's water. and taslima, rushdie and christian prof in kerala. personally i believe india is amazingly secular even in intolerance.
:D
by the way, it is chattisgarh govt. not MP and i doubt whether international or public pressure influence SC's verdict. as for chattisgarh govt. they are still pursuing a case against sen, but probably without the sedition charge.
just for clarification , i don't claim india is very tolerant. i was just claiming that the lack of michael moore has a different reason. but let's agree to disagree.
after my two long posts now i am feeling silly because of this arakshan controversy.
ReplyDelete:D
@carvaka--I saw The Final Solution by Sharma and yikes! I took down my Hindu mythology post.
ReplyDelete